Archive for December, 2008
By sschablow December 10, 2008
Beth Harte recently wrote a blog post asking if social media is scalable. She asserted that once hundreds or thousands join the conversation, one person/company cannot continue a two-way conversation. She concludes: “Two-way conversations are not scalable. Once they reach the tipping point, two-way conversations revert back to one-way conversations (or the community conversing amongst [...]
Beth Harte recently wrote a blog post asking if social media is scalable. She asserted that once hundreds or thousands join the conversation, one person/company cannot continue a two-way conversation. She concludes:
“Two-way conversations are not scalable. Once they reach the tipping point, two-way conversations revert back to one-way conversations (or the community conversing amongst themselves). At this point, Web 2.0 tools join the arsenal of traditional marketing tools (such as direct marketing, e-mail marketing, PR, advertising, etc.) to continue mass, one-way communication efforts.”
I don’t disagree, but I do have a slightly different perspective. That is, done correctly, social media IS scalable. In fact for it to become a valuable tool for any company is MUST be scalable. Take Comcast for instance. They have at least 8 customer services representatives actively engaging customers on Twitter. Dell computers also has several official reps there too. They may not all be in the same conversation, but they are still all having a Comcast discussion. Much like the small groups that form at a very large party.
Zappos and others have created a scalable scenario by encouraging and empowering the entire staff to be brand evangelists through social media (Twitter specifically, but expansion beyond that platform is inevitable). I recall reading a post (can’t remember who, thinking Mack Collier) that said, in essence, think of the benefits a large corporation would receive if they took a million dollars from the ad budget and hired a staff of ’social media relations’ experts to, listen, blog, comment on blogs, and Tweet all day, every day.
Which would have more of a positive effect on the bottom line? A couple of network TV ads that were largely ignored or several hundred (or thousand) customers transformed into enthusiastic brand ambassadors through meaningful conversations. Corporate marketing directors easily discount the idea, claiming they have a consumer affairs hotline that can address issues in real time. When, in the real world, they perform below consumers expectations. On the phone they are expected to be reactive, concerned and compassionate. Regulatory and legal constraints prevent them from offering what the consumer expects. In a social media setting, the consumer is sought out and contacted proactively, which generally impresses the consumer.
Just as the editor of the New York Sun Time proclaimed to Virginia, yes, there is a Santa Claus, I submit that, yes, Social Media IS scalable. It just depends on your belief in the value of it and your commitment to fully funding social media relations in your company.
What do You think? Post a comment and join the conversation.